As we all know, motherhood is inherently sexistmen cant be mothers if men cant be mothers, then they wont lose pay because of motherhood. What doesnt serve women very well is for them or sandberg or obama or hillary to perpetuate the myth that women make 77 cents per dollar. Nov 22, 2015 i have long been insisting that we dont in fact have a gender pay gap. If we want to have a fruitful discussion about a gender wage gap, we. Many women sacrifice pay for all sorts of reasons including security, safety, flexibility, and fulfillment. The gender wage gap remains a stubborn fact of life for working americans.
The more feminized a job, the less people will pay for someone to do it. Pay gap myth ignores womens intentional job choices. Gender wage gap no myth, just math the clarionledger. A pew report released in december seemed to bring good news. Apr 01, 2017 but to borrow a phrase from aauw, the gender pay gap is all math, not myth. Reasons for the gender pay gap dont include this major myth. Every year, twice a year on international womens day and today, socalled equal pay day figures are trotted. Six stubborn myths about equal pay between men and women. Its not a myth goldman sachs reveals gender pay gap however its not as common as people make out. Its not a measure of whether a man and woman, working the exact same hours in the exact same position in the. Mar 30, 2017 the ongoing battle over gender equality has turned the question of the relative pay of women and men into quite the political football. Our latest freakonomics radio episode is called the true story of the gender pay gap.
The spurious assertion that women are paid 77 cents for a mans wage dollar comes from comparing the earnings of all fulltime men with those of all. In particular, this blog post is closely related to our article on the determinants of the gender pay gap, as well as to the article on the determinants of female labor force participation this blog post benefitted greatly from research contributions provided by sandra tzvetkova. In this post, we argue that the figure is an accurate measure of the inequality in earnings. Harvard study confirms the gender wage gap is just a myth. Aug 11, 2014 t he gender pay gap was in the news again last week, after a report found that at the current rate of change it would be another 60 years before women are paid equally to men. There is a gap, but i do not think most of it is because women are women or men are men, necessarily. For one thing, the pay gap can be measured in three different ways. May 30, 20 the biggest myth about the gender wage gap the real gap isnt between men and women doing the same job. While many will claim that the gender pay gap is not a real thing. In australias industrial relations system, it is illegal to pay a woman a less than a man when theyre employed to do identical jobs which is why you might be thinking that the gender pay gap is not real. Reuters photo tuesday was equal pay day, a day set aside to perpetuate the myth of the gender pay gap, which claims that, because of gender discrimination, women receive about 22 percent lower pay on average for doing the same work as men. The myth of the gender wage gap is one thats had particularly long legs.
Jul 15, 2016 much has been said and written about the gender gap in tech, including the disparity in pay between men and women. Below is a transcript of the episode, modified for your reading pleasure. Apr 17, 2011 a new report reinforces the widely accepted myth of a gender pay gap. Every year, twice a year on international womens day and today, socalled equal pay day figures are trotted out that show on average, women earn less than. However, after adjusting for choices made by male and female workers in college major, occupation, working hours and. This past week, people celebrated equal pay day, the supposed day when women finally earned as much as men had in the past year. The gender wage gap is a dangerous myth charisma news. On equal pay day, we tackled the five most common myths and misconceptions about the gender pay gap.
No matter how many times this wage gap claim is decisively refuted by economists, it always comes back. Five myths about unequal pay ellie mae ohagan opinion. Pay gap myth ignores womens intentional job choices the. This is the biggest myth about the gender pay gap london.
How well do biological gender differences explain the. Pay gap studies disprove myth that sexism is responsible. These unsupported claims, along with such claims as women receive smaller first time research grants than their male colleagues, are not in the. More recently, critics have replied that its not a myth and that those who think it is a myth are peddling. Statistics canada data shows a gender pay gap still exists.
The gender pay gap is a fashionable myth institute of. The gender wage gap myth and 5 other feminist fantasies time. Apr 14, 2016 most of the gap is explained by personal choices made by millions of individual women and men, writes brett arends. Share on facebook share on twitter share via email. A 2016 study conducted by researchers at cornell university determined that job type is one of the single greatest contributors to an enduring gender wage gap. The gender pay gap is largely a myth the spectator. Five myths about the gender pay gap the washington post. The gender wage gap is absolutely real numerous studies across cultures and time periods have supported the reality of the gender wage gap. Their choice of jobs and working a lot of overtime. Despite women reaching higher levels of educational attainment, there has not been an associated decrease in the pay gap between women and men. In the united states, according to an estimate published by the institute for womens policy research, the wage gap will not close at this rate until 2058, which is another generation away for women of today. The encouraging lessons from this book will inspire women to embrace careers that.
But the figures are an important indicator of structural inequality. The not a myth argument consists of theories and opinions. It is a myth that stems from the flawed talking point that women earn 79 cents for every dollar a man earns. The gender pay gap is not a myth its a shameful truth. The entire gender pay gap explained in just one number. Yet regardless of all the research, there are many people who say that the gender pay gap is a myth.
The gender wage gap is a serious issue and can limit women in terms of both earning potential and promotions. Debunking the gender pay gap myth its just a tool for 2017s identity politics. In the united states, according to an estimate published by the institute for womens policy research, the wage gap will not close. Nov 15, 2017 yet regardless of all the research, there are many people who say that the gender pay gap is a myth. The gender pay gap is a myth, i may have made back the income ive. To put it simply, its a matter of mens and womens choices.
For example, women earn 15% less than men per hour. Timess gender editor and author of the book feminist fight club, to. The most extreme myth is that gender pay gap is a lie perpetuated by feminists who use statistics dishonestly to. The pay gap is narrowing, and millennial women are nearly at parity with millennial men. Our world in data presents the empirical evidence on global development in articles dedicated to specific topics. Over the last few years, defenders of markets, including me, have been on the offensive, arguing that the gender pay gap is in some sense a myth. Nearly every dollar that men are paid in excess of women can be explained by something that has nothing to do with oppression or sexism. Its women who decide to work part time or not pursue stem fields. The gender pay gap in the united states is the ratio of femaletomale median or average depending on the source yearly earnings among fulltime, yearround workers the average womans unadjusted annual salary has been cited as 81% to 82% of that of the average mans. The idea that gender determines the pay gap is disproven by serious research, but that doesnt kill the old lie that prejudice and sexism are responsible. Five ways to win an argument about the gender wage gap. The myth part is a bit provocative and i accept a gap exists, its just the reasons why it exists isnt due to the patriarchy or discrimination against women, but can be explained due to the different choices women make and. Americas gender pay gap is a myth national economics editorial. If i had a nickel for every time someone told me, the gender pay gap is a myth, i may have made back the income ive lost over the years for being a woman.
Controversial and exhaustively researched, gender expert warren farrells latest book why men earn more takes as its stunning argument the idea that biasbased unequal pay for women is largely a myth, and that women are most often paid less than men not because they are discriminated against, but because they have made lifestyle choices that affect their ability to earn. The gender pay gap is not a result of discrimination, coercion, or anything like that. This is a view shared by a small but vocal coalition of rightwing think tanks, jordan peterson, and mens rights activists. The gender wage gap is as real as unicorns and has been killed more times than michael myers.
And low female wages were not simply an expression of this worldview, they also helped to create it. Over half a century after pay discrimination became illegal in the united states, a persistent pay gap between men and women continues to hurt our nations workers and our national economy. Apr 12, 2016 dont buy into the gender pay gap myth. It turns out that accounting for all these factors eliminates all but an estimated 3 to 5 cents of the gender pay gap. The myth is that the gender wage gap is a true distinction in talent between men and women. Dont believe what all the politicians, feminists groups, and womens councils say when men and women do the same job, they earn the same pay. Female prostitutes make way more money than male prostitutes for doing exactly the same job.
It is no wonder college women buy into this 78 cent pay gap myth. Truth and myth on the gender pay gap foundation for. The guiding idea is that, because women make 77% of what men make for the same work, that from oct. And yet the nuance required to explain what perpetuates these misconceptions is not the. Right after winning an academy award, patricia arquette proclaimed that its our time to have wage equality once and for all and equal rights for women in the united states of america to thunderous applause.
The idea of the gender pay gap is mostly bogus marketwatch. Here are 7 myths about the gender wage gap that need to be busted once and for all. A new report reinforces the widely accepted myth of a gender pay gap. I am called on to counter arguments about the gender pay gap being a myth, or that the gender. In 20, median weekly earnings for women working full time were 82 percent of mens, with hispanic women earning only 62 percent and black women 69 percent of white mens pay. And if were being honest women make more than men for similar work, because of less competition, more government handouts, and affirmative action programs etc. Apr 07, 2018 a newly published report on the gender pay gap attempts to reframe the debate by changing the metric.
Maybe not in the corner office, a study shows despite the efforts of some companies to address a gender pay disparity, women still earn less than men. The gender pay gap is not a result of discrimination, coercion or anything like that. The state of gender pay gap 2019 based on a survey of 1. Should we mind the gap gender pay differentials and public policy by j. The gender pay gap is not a myth, but it might not mean exactly what you think. I dont think the pay gap stats really deal with the issues. On equal pay day 2019, how to confront myths of gender pay.
Mar, 2018 this makes it more urgent than ever that we debunk myths about the falsity of the gender pay gap. As the world economic forum is underway in davos, switzerland, we thought it fitting to highlight one of the most pressing economic issues in america today. Female colleagues do not ask for a rise, and other persistent. The most extreme myth is that gender pay gap is a lie perpetuated by feminists who use statistics dishonestly to further their cause. Sep 30, 2016 factual feminist s2 e4 gender activists dismayed by this new reason for the wage gap factual feminist duration. If job a pays progressively due to increasing experience, then people who stay in the job longest will end up with more pay. There may be a number of intricate, deepseated economic and social factors at play when it comes to the gender pay gap, but there are an equal number of actions that all of us can take to help level the playing field. April 10th is equal pay day, but there are still plenty of myths out there about the gender pay gap. If we want to have a fruitful discussion about a gender wage gap, we should have it after the comparison is adjusted for those factors. Women earn 77 cents for every dollar a man earnsfor doing the same work. This is the biggest myth about the gender pay gap what is equal pay day and why should we take notice. Theres a widespread misunderstanding about the gender pay gap in america. Sep 16, 2016 updated september 11, 2019 the 82 percent wage ratio figure, the most commonly used figure to measure the gender wage gap in the united states, is often derided as misleading, a myth, or worst of all, a lie. The ongoing battle over gender equality has turned the question of the relative pay of women and men into quite the political football.
I asked the gender editor of the times to walk us through the details. But the white house and others who promote the myth are manipulating statistics in a way to convince women that they are the victims of systematic societal discrimination, and, therefore, stand to benefit from further government action. The pay gap figure is bogus because it does not reflect likeforlike pay gaps for employees in the same or comparable roles. The gender pay gap is not a myth its a shameful truth i do wonder what if there was no gender pay gap, would the expectation still fall on women to take breaks from their careers to care for. The biggest myth about the gender wage gap the atlantic. Stella creasy discusses the gender pay gap on sky news. Those who choose not recognize the gender pay gap may say its because women decide to choose which professionindustries they want to work in. The gender pay gap is the difference in average hourly rates of pay between. Even the famously leftleaning new york times has begun quietly revealing the truth about the supposed gender pay gap in america. Hoover institution senior fellow thomas sowell argues that economic differences between working men and women are not generally due to employer discrimination, as is widely alleged. Apr 05, 2018 the wright stuff panel discuss whether gender pay gaps really are discriminatory towards women with think tank expert kate andrews, who claims other factors like experience, time out for children. The notion that women earn less than men has become an accepted truth. Not that it matters to the left, but a study from harvard university titled why do women earn less than men.
You can subscribe to the podcast at itunes or elsewhere, get the rss feed, or listen via the media player above. Almost half of men and 30 percent of women believe the gender pay gap has been made up to serve a political purpose and is not a legitimate issue, according to. Among the proposals it is considering are an extension of mandatory reporting of organisational pay gaps to smaller businesses currently only those employing 250 workers are required to report and the development of action plans to reduce continue reading the gender pay gap is a fashionable myth. Debunking the gender pay gap mythits just a tool for 2017s identity politics. They are still not majoring in the stem fields to the same extent as men and believe me, women are as smart as men. I hate to be possibly pedantic, but thats a study on the earnings gap, not the pay gap the gender pay gap is the difference between the average earnings of men and women, expressed relative to mens earnings. There most certainly is a gender based pay gap for doing the same work. Americas gender pay gap is a myth national economics. Its between the different jobs that men and women take. Shackleton and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at.
1328 1105 697 743 468 1562 965 1486 982 1150 207 1508 71 1049 1661 1565 1194 925 175 817 599 542 1364 581 544 440 1492 233 1370 334 455